District Court, E.D. Virginia September 2, 2003, CIV. 03-697-A (RZS HOLDINGS, AVV v. Commerzbank, Ag)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-09-2003

MEMORANDUM OPINION

CACHERIS, District Judge.

This matter is before the Court on the defendant’s motion to dismiss.

I. Background

This dispute arises out of the dishonor of a letter of credit issued in connection with a multi-party international commercial transaction. In this action, plaintiff RZS Holdings, AW (“Plaintiff’ or “RZS”), a Virginia partnership with its principal place of business in Virginia, was the beneficiary of a letter of credit. In fact, RZS brings this suit against defendant Com-merzbank, AG (“Commerzbank” or “Defendant”), a German organization with its principal place of business in Germany, for wrongfully dishonoring that letter of credit.

This letter of credit dispute is rooted in a transaction between RZS and the state oil company of Venezuela PdVSA, Petról-eos, S.A. (“PdVSA”). In that underlying transaction, RZS agreed to provide PdVSA with over 400,000 barrels of gasoline, which RZS would acquire from Vitol, S.A., a Dutch petroleum concern. According to the underlying contract, RZS was required to ship the gasoline to PdVSA in Venezuela. In return, PdVSA would have a letter of credit issued for the benefit of RZS.

*718

Specifically, PdVSA contracted with Ban-esco Banco Universal (“Banesco”), a Venezuelan bank to issue a letter of credit for the benefit of RZS. The letter of credit provided that it could only be confirmed by Commerzbank and drawn upon at Com-merzbank’s branch in London, England.

On April 10 and 11, 2003, RZS attempted to draw on the letter of credit at Com-merzbank’s London office by presenting certain documents required under the terms of the letter of credit. Commerz-bank refused to honor the letter of credit, however, claiming that the documents presented did not comply with the requirements of the letter of credit agreement. RZS now brings this suit generally asserting that Commerzbank’s dishonor was wrongful.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.