District Court, N.D. Indiana March 24, 2003, 1:01 CV 352 (Cohen v. Orthalliance New Image, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-03-2003

ORDER

MOODY, District Judge.

In this action, the parties have cross-moved for summary judgment. During the time allotted for briefing the motions, this action was transferred from the Fort Wayne Division to the Hammond Division, at which time the random judicial assignment system placed the case before the undersigned. Upon review of the record compiled by the parties, the court resolves the pending motions as explained in the remainder of this Order.

I. BACKGROUND

Cohen is a Doctor of Dental Surgery, who specializes in orthodontia. He practices his profession in Allen County, Indiana under the name Cohen Orthodontic Group, P.C. (“Cohen Orthodontic”), of which Cohen owns all outstanding stock. (See PI. Desig. Of Evid. at Ex. B (“Complaint”) at ¶¶ 4-5.)

Orthalliance New Image, Inc. (“New Image”) is a Delaware corporation with its primary place of business in Torrance, California. (See

id.

at ¶ 3.) New Image manages orthodontic practices throughout the country. (See Def. Desig. of Evid. at Ex. 1 (“Summers Aff”) at ¶4.) As part of the furious consolidation experienced in the orthodontic practice management industry during 2000 and 2001, New Image was purchased by Orthalliance, Inc.

1

in an asset deal. (See

id.

at ¶ 20.)

See generally Top Public Companies: Orthodontic Centers of America, OCA now dominates field,

New Orleans City Bus., June 17, 2002, at 27,

available at

2002 WL 12346069. Orthalliance, Inc. was subsequently acquired by another competitor, Orthodontic Centers of America.

See id.

Thus, Orthalliance, Inc. acts as both the parent of New Image and the subsidiary of Orthodontic Centers of America.

The relationship between Cohen and New Image began in early 1997. At the time, New Image

2

was a corporate infant, but eager to take advantage of the expanding market for orthodontic practice services.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.