District Court, Virgin Islands August 22, 2003, CIV.2001-228 (Sharp v. Government of the Virgin Islands)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-08-2003

MEMORANDUM

MOORE, District Judge.

On May 12, 2003,1 found the Territory’s property tax system unlawful because it “systemically employ[ed] a method of assessment not calculated to determine the actual value of properties as required by 48 U.S.C. § 1401a.”

Berne Corp. v. Government of the Virgin Islands,

262 F.Supp.2d 540, 561 (D.Vi.2003)

[Berne Corp. II

]. Accordingly, I entered a decree in the consolidated portion of this case awarding injunctive and other such relief common to all parties. All that remains for resolution in this case is application of this decree to the unique facts posed in this individual action brought by plaintiff Elisabeth Sharp [“Sharp” or “plaintiff’], including her request for declaratory relief regarding the actual value of the parcels of real property she owns.

I. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Sharp is a Virgin Islands resident who owns residential properties on St. Thomas known as Parcel Nos. 109 and 109-1 Estate Contant. Upon her belief that the Government was vastly overstating the value of her properties for property tax purposes, Sharp filed timely appeals of with the Board of Tax Review. Despite the fact that some of these appeals have been pending since 1996, the Board of Tax Review failed to conduct timely hearings. In fact, it was not until January 2000 that the Board of Tax Review even held a hearing on plaintiffs 1996-1999 tax bills. Moreover, even though it held this hearing in January 2000, the Board of Tax Review did not issue its purported ruling until May 7, 2002 when this case was already on-going. Having received no relief from the Board of Tax Review, plaintiff sued the defendants in this Court alleging that the Government had illegally assessed the val

*587

ue of her properties based on replacement value, rather than the actual value required by federal law.

At the trial of this individual case, Sharp presented much evidence in support of her valuations of her properties.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.