Court of Appeals of Oregon May 29, 2003, D0104323M; A117141 (State v. Touchstone)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-05-2003
*47
BREWER, P. J.
Defendant and the state have filed a joint motion for an order vacating the judgment convicting defendant of harassment, ORS 166.065(1)(a)(A), and directing the trial court to enter a judgment for attempted harassment and to resentence defendant accordingly. We grant the motion.
1
Defendant appeals from his conviction of a single count of harassment. The accusatory instrument alleged:
“The defendant, on or about August 26, 2001, in Washington County, Oregon, did unlawfully and with the intent to harass and annoy [the victim], subject [the victim] to offensive physical contact.”
After he was convicted of the charged offense, defendant filed a motion in arrest of judgment in which he argued that the facts alleged in the accusatory instrument “do not constitute an offense.” ORS 135.630(4). Defendant argued that he could not be convicted of harassment because ORS 166.065(1)(a)(A), the version of the offense with which he was charged, requires that the victim actually be annoyed or harassed, and the charging instrument did not include that allegation. Although the state conceded that defendant was correct, the trial court refused to accept the concession, and it entered judgment on the harassment conviction. Defendant renews his argument on appeal.
The state charged defendant under ORS 166.065, which provides, in part:
*48
The statutory element that the victim be harassed or annoyed is an essential one, without which an accusatory instrument would not state the crime charged.
Cf. State v. Wimber,
315 Or 103, 114-15, 843 P2d 424 (1992) (in determining whether an amendment to an accusatory instrument is one of substance or form, the question is whether, without the amendment, the remaining allegations of the instrument allege each of the essential elements of the charged offense).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit