Court of Appeals of Washington November 13, 2003, 21431-1-III (State v. Zumwalt)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-11-2003
82 P.3d 672 (2003) 119 Wash.App. 126 STATE of Washington, Respondent, v. William Lars ZUMWALT, Appellant. No. 21431-1-III. Court of Appeals of Washington, Division 3, Panel Nine. November 13, 2003. *673 Sharon M. Brown, Attorney at Law, Pasco, WA, for Appellant. Terry J. Bloor, Deputy Prosecuting Attorney, Kennewick, WA, for Respondent. SWEENEY, J. Under the statutory doctrine of merger, two offenses constitute a single crime where, in order to establish the elements of one offense, the State must prove that a second crime was committed. Here, the State had to prove the second degree assault to establish robbery in the first degree. The assault, therefore, merged into the robbery. Accordingly, we reverse the assault conviction. FACTS William Zumwalt joined some friends, including Elwood Davis, Jeremy Vannauker, and Johnnie Allen, at the Fiesta Bowl Casino in Richland, Washington. Denise Schaffer was also there. Ms. Schaffer gave Mr. Vannauker $60 to buy drugs and agreed to give him another $60 upon delivery. Mr. Zumwalt and the others left the casino to complete the deal with Ms. Schaffer. Ms. Schaffer, Mr. Zumwalt, and Mr. Davis left the casino within seconds of each other and met up outside. Mr. Allen, Mr. Vannauker, and a female member of Mr. Zumwalt's party also left at about the same time. Outside, Ms. Schaffer stood with Mr. Davis and Mr. Zumwalt. She turned and one or both of them struck her. She was seriously injured a fractured eye socket and bruising of her eyes that lasted for two weeks. Her vision remains impaired. About $300 in cash and casino chips was taken from the front pocket of her coveralls. Ms. Schaffer could not positively identify either who assaulted her or who took her money. Mr. Zumwalt admitted to the police that he assaulted Ms. Schaffer. He also told the officer that he knew Ms. Schaffer had been robbed. But he denied robbing her. He said he became concerned that Ms.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit