District Court, M.D. Pennsylvania October 8, 2003, CIV.A.3:CV-98-2070 (United States Ex Rel. Paranich v. Sorgnard)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-10-2003

MEMORANDUM

CONNER, District Judge.

Presently before the court is defendant Irwin Leasing Corporation’s (“Irwin”) motion for summary judgment. (Doc. 125). This is a

qui

tam

1

action under the False Claims Act, 31 U.S.C. §§ 3729

et seq.

(“the Act”).

Qui tam

plaintiff,

2

Steven Paranich (“Paranich”), contends that Irwin induced him to file false Medicare reimbursement claims for treatments using a medical device called the Matrix. Irwin denies any liability for plaintiffs Medicare claims, and asserts that, even if it is liable, Paranich is not a proper relator under the Act. Irwin also asserts via counterclaim that Paranich must indemnify Irwin for the expense of defending the instant action.

Irwin moves for summary judgment on Paranich’s claims under the False Claims Act and for partial summary judgment on the issue of liability under its indemnity counterclaim. The parties have fully briefed the issues, and the motion is now ripe for disposition. For the following reasons, the court will dismiss this matter for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.

I.

Factual Background

The following facts are undisputed.

3

Irwin is a corporation that finances the purchase of equipment through leases. (Doc. 127, ¶ 1). Defendant Matrix Biokinetics, Inc., is a corporation that previously sold medical devices throughout the United States.

Id.

¶ 2. Beginning on January 1, 1994, Matrix Biokineties marketed and sold electric nerve stimulation devices known as the Matrix Pro Elec DT and Matrix Pro Elec DT2 (“the Matrix”).

Id.

¶ 3.

*448

Paranich is a chiropractor practicing in Pennsylvania.

Id.

¶ 5. He is co-owner of Comprehensive Medical Network (“CMN”), a multi-disciplinary clinic with offices in Pennsylvania.

Id.

¶ 6. In November or December 1996, Paranich and CMN decided to acquire a Matrix device.

Id.

¶ 7. To aid CMN in the acquisition of the Matrix, an independent sales representative arranged for financing of the equipment in the form of leases with Irwin.

Id.

¶8.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.