District Court, D. Colorado September 25, 2003, CIV. 97-B-1955 (Villescas v. Abraham)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-09-2003

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

BABCOCK, Chief Judge.

I. Background

Plaintiff Carlos Villescas sued the Department of Energy in 1997 under the anti-retaliation provisions of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, 42 U.S.C. § 2000e

et seq.,

and the ADEA, 29 U.S.C.A. § 621

et seq.

Plaintiff argued that Defendant severely retaliated against him for his testimony in a co-worker’s ADEA and Title VII trial that tended to support the co-worker’s claims. A trial was held in Plaintiffs case in December 2000. His Title VII claim was presented to the jury. He tried his ADEA claim to the Court.

The jury found that Defendant’s conduct did not constitute “adverse action” under Title VII and returned a verdict for the Department of Energy. The jury came to its verdict only after Defendant reversed its long-held, pre-trial position that Plaintiff was “an adulterer and nepotist.” Throughout the pre-trial portion of the case, Defendant relentlessly asserted this position. Conversely, Defendant’s counsel in her opening statement did not maintain these allegations. In fact, it soon became ' clear that Defendant no longer adhered to his pre-trial position. Before the jury, Defendant even denied making such accusations. Plaintiff vigorously denied Defendant’s allegations and continues to deny them.

Plaintiff constructed his case based on the harm and damage caused by Defendant’s imputations. Both Plaintiffs counsel and I were “stunned,”

see

Appellee’s Supplemental Appendix, 29-35, at Defendant’s reversal and denial of its long-held position. I was clear in my disdain for this underhanded trial tactic:

*1252

[Throughout this case the government has called Mr. Villescas an adulterer, an incestuous person, throughout this case, in the pleadings in this case. Now we get to trial-you know, ‘We never said he was an adulterer’.... It’s outrageous .... You have littered the paper in this case, which is now public record, calling Mr. Villescas an adulterer, a nepotist.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.