District Court, W.D. New York February 23, 2003, 1:00-cv-00051 (Gateway Equipment Corp. v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-02-2003
INTRODUCTION
CURTIN, District Judge.
Plaintiff Gateway Equipment Corporation (“Gateway”) brought two actions
1
*301
against the United States for the recovery of excise taxes. In the first action, docketed as 00-CV-51, Gateway alleged that taxes in the amount of $15,534.00 were erroneously and illegally assessed against and collected from it during the taxable quarter ending June 30, 1995. Item 1. Shortly after the first action was filed, Gateway filed another action against the United States to recover additional excise taxes in the amount of $105,823.00 assessed and collected during seven taxable quarters ranging from June 30, 1992 to December 31,1994. That case, originally docketed as OO-CV-124, was consolidated with the present action. Item 38. The excise taxes were assessed on sales of Flow Boy Live Bottom semitrailers, model CB-4000 (“CB-4000 units”), used in highway construction and manufactured by Flow Boy Manufacturing (“Flow Boy Mfg.”), a division of Dan Hill & Associates, Inc., Norman, Oklahoma. During the time period of this case, Gateway was a distributor of Flow Boy equipment. It purchased the CB-4000 units from Flow Boy Mfg. for resale to customers (“end-users”) in the highway construction business, and added the 12 percent excise tax to the cost of the machine. It then paid the excise tax to the Internal Revenue Service.
The government answered, Item 2, and on April 5, 2000, Gateway moved for summary judgment. Items 4 — 6. Gateway based its summary judgment argument on three grounds: (1) collateral estoppel premised on a previous decision in
Flow Boy, Inc. v. United States,
1984 WL 15513 (10th Cir. Jan. 20, 1984); (2) the United States has treated Gateway differently than “similarly situated” taxpayers; and (3) the CB-4000, by its design, is excepted from the Federal Excise Tax (“FET”) in Treasury Regulation 26 C.F.R. § 48.4061(a)-l (2001).
The court ordered discovery to proceed on the first two grounds, collateral estop-pel and fairness. Item 7.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit