California Supreme Court June 2, 2003, S108751 (Winter v. DC Comics)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-06-2003
Opinion
CHIN, J.
Celebrities have a statutory right of publicity by which they can prohibit others from using their likeness. (Civ. Code, § 3344.) An obvious tension exists between this right of publicity and the First Amendment to the United States Constitution.
(Comedy III Productions, Inc. v. Gary Saderup, Inc.
(2001) 25 Cal.4th 387, 396 [106 Cal.Rptr.2d 126, 21 P.3d 797]
(Comedy III).)
In
Comedy
III, we considered when constitutional free speech rights may trump the statutory right of publicity. We formulated “what is essentially a balancing test between the First Amendment and the right of publicity based on whether the work in question adds significant creative elements so as to be transformed into something more than a mere celebrity likeness or imitation.”
(Id.
at p. 391.) In that case, we concluded that lithographs and T-shirts bearing the likeness of The Three Stooges were not sufficiently transformative to receive First Amendment protection.
In this case, we apply the same balancing test to comic books containing characters that evoke musician brothers Johnny and Edgar Winter. We conclude that, in contrast to a drawing of The Three Stooges, the comic books do contain significant creative elements that transform them into something more than mere celebrity likenesses. Accordingly, the comic books are entitled to First Amendment protection.
*886
I. Facts and Procedural History
In the 1990’s, DC Comics published a five-volume comic miniseries featuring “Jonah Hex,” a fictional comic book “anti-hero.” The series contains an outlandish plot, involving giant worm-like creatures, singing cowboys, and the “Wilde West Ranch and Music and Culture Emporium,” named for and patterned after the life of Oscar Wilde. The third volume ends with a reference to two new characters, the “Autumn brothers,” and the teaser, “Next: The Autumns of Our Discontent.” The cover of volume 4 depicts the Autumn brother characters, with pale faces and long white hair. (See append.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit