Washington Supreme Court May 22, 2003, 72554-3 (Pacheco v. Ames)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-05-2003
69 P.3d 324 (2003) 149 Wash.2d 431 Keith A. PACHECO, Petitioner, v. John R. AMES, D.D.S., a sole proprietor, Respondent, Thomas F. Whitfield, D.D.S., a sole proprietor, Defendant. No. 72554-3. Supreme Court of Washington, En Banc. Argued February 27, 2003. Decided May 22, 2003. *325 Keith S. Douglass & Associates, Patrick Fannin, Spokane, for Petitioner. Lawrence & Versnel, John Versnel, James Owen, Jr., Seattle, for Respondent. Preston Thorgrimson et al., Martha Raymond, Shipla Bhatia, Seattle, Amicus Curiae on Behalf of Wa. Defense Trial Lawyers. ALEXANDER, C.J. A Spokane County Superior Court jury awarded Keith Pacheco damages for an injury he sustained while he was undergoing oral surgery performed by Dr. John Ames, D.D.S. The Court of Appeals reversed the judgment that was based on the jury verdict, concluding that the trial court improperly instructed the jury on the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur. Pacheco challenges that decision, asserting that he (1) satisfied the elements of the res ipsa loquitur doctrine, and (2) properly relied on the doctrine notwithstanding the fact that Dr. Ames offered testimony which explained how the injury could have occurred without negligence. We agree with Pacheco and reverse the Court of Appeals. I. In August 1996 Keith Pacheco was diagnosed by his dentist, Dr. Thomas Whitfield, D.D.S., with three impacted wisdom teeth. Whitfield referred Pacheco to an oral surgeon, Dr. John Ames, D.D.S, for extraction of the teeth. The teeth which were to be removed were the two upper wisdom teeth and the lower right wisdom tooth, designated numbers 1, 16, and 32, respectively. Before the surgery took place, Whitfield sent Ames *326 a Panorex x-ray[1] of Pacheco's teeth. In one corner of the x-ray there was a mark which Ames later stated he may have interpreted as an "LR" meaning "lower right." Partial Verbatim Report of Proceedings (RP) at 100. Ames performed the oral surgery on September 23, 1996.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit