Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit September 16, 2003, 02-1354 (United States v. Abdullah Alhumoz - errata)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-09-2003
USA v Alhumoz
02-1354
Errata Filed: September 9, 2003
REENA RAGGI, Circuit Judge, concurring in part and dissenting in part:
1 I concur in the court’s opinion insofar as it (1) declines to address Alhumoz’s challenge to
2 the effectiveness of his trial counsel and (2) affirms a sentencing enhancement for gross receipts
3 of more than $1 million. I respectfully dissent, however, from Part III, which concludes that the
4 district court clearly erred when it enhanced Alhumoz’s sentence for obstruction of justice
5 pursuant to U.S.S.G. § 3C1.1. Specifically, I disagree with the majority’s view that there is no
6 evidence in this case of “words or conduct by the defendant” supporting “an inference that he
7 specifically intended to obstruct justice.” [See ante at 13.] While direct evidence of words or
8 conduct may be lacking, there is considerable circumstantial evidence supporting an inference of
9 obstructive conduct by Alhumoz. Indeed, the district court made a specific factual finding of
10 such conduct, ruling that a computer was moved from Alhumoz’s office “specifically at the
11 defendant’s direction,” and with his specific intent “to obstruct justice.” Sentencing Trans., May
12 30, 2002, at 29-30 (emphasis added).
13 Preliminary to discussing this circumstantial evidence, I note that this appeal does not
14 require us to engage in de novo review of whether the conduct at issue constitutes obstruction of
15 justice under § 3C1.1. See United States v. Cassiliano, 137 F.3d 742, 745 (2d Cir. 1998)
16 (holding that whether established facts constitute obstruction under the sentencing guidelines is
17 “a matter of legal interpretation”).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit