Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces January 9, 2003, 02-0443/AR (United States v. Gibson)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-2003

UNITED STATES, Appellee

v.

Scott D. GIBSON, Private

U.S. Army, Appellant

No. 02-0443

Crim. App. No. 9900573

United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces

Argued November 6, 2002

Decided January 9, 2003

GIERKE, J., delivered the opinion of the Court, in which

CRAWFORD, C.J., EFFRON, BAKER, and ERDMANN, JJ., joined.

Counsel

For Appellant: Captain Brian S. Heslin (argued); Colonel Robert

D. Teetsel, Lieutenant Colonel E. Allen Chandler, Jr., and

Major Imogene M. Jamison (on brief); and Colonel Adele H.

Odegard.

For Appellee: Captain Abraham F. Carpio (argued); Lieutenant

Colonel Margaret B. Baines, Lieutenant Colonel Lauren B.

Leeker, Major Mark L. Johnson (on brief); and Captain

Theodore C. Houdek.

Military Judge: Donna M. Wright

This opinion is subject to editorial correction before final publication.

United States v. Gibson, No. 02-0443/AR

Judge GIERKE delivered the opinion of the Court.

A general court-martial composed of officer members

convicted Appellant, contrary to his pleas, of conspiring to

commit premeditated murder, violating a general regulation by

possessing drug paraphernalia, making a false official statement,

and wrongfully possessing and using marijuana, in violation of

Articles 81, 92, 107, and 112a, Uniform Code of Military Justice,

10 U.S.C. §§ 881, 892, 907, and 912a (2002), respectively. The

adjudged and approved sentence provides for a dishonorable

discharge, confinement for five years, and total forfeitures.

The Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the findings and sentence

without opinion.

This Court granted review of the following issue:

WHETHER THE MILITARY JUDGE ERRED IN REFUSING TO GIVE A

REQUESTED ACCOMPLICE INSTRUCTION AT APPELLANT’S COURT-

MARTIAL.

For the reasons set out below, we hold that the military judge

erred.

Factual Background

In February 1998, Private First Class (PFC) Toni Bell

hired Private (PV1) Kurtis Armann to kill the father of her

oldest child. PFC Bell believed that the father was attempting

to gain custody.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.