Vermont Superior Court September 22, 2003, S0826 (Travelers Ins. Cos. v. Demarle, Inc. USA)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-09-2003

Traveler’s Insurance v. DeMarle, No. 826-99 Cncv (Katz, J., Sept. 22,

2003)

[The text of this Vermont trial court opinion is unofficial. It has been

reformatted from the original. The accuracy of the text and the

accompanying data included in the Vermont trial court opinion database is

not guaranteed.]

STATE OF VERMONT SUPERIOR COURT

Chittenden County, ss.: Docket No. 826-99 CnCv

TRAVELERS INS. CO’S.

V.

DEMARLE, INC. U.S.A.

ENTRY

Greyston Bakery and their insurance company Travelers (hereinafter

Bakery) seek compensation from the defendant Demarle, Inc. based on four

counts: 1) Products Liability, 2) Warranty, 3) Negligence, and 4) Indemnity

and Compensation. Demarle seeks to dismiss all claims on a motion for

summary judgment.

Greyston Bakery is a New York Corporation that manufacturers

baked goods. These goods are not sold through retail but to other

companies that incorporate them into their products or repackage them as

their “house” brand. Bakery bakes several hundred pounds of brownies

each year for their single largest customer, Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream, which

uses them in its New York Super Fudge Chunk Brownie ice cream and

yogurt. In the beginning of October 1997, Quality Assurance at Ben &

Jerry’s noticed small fibers in the brownies from Bakery. Ben & Jerry’s

notified Bakery about the problem. Further sampling led to more fibers,

and Ben & Jerry’s decided to dispose of 47,000 gallons of potentially

contaminated brownie ice cream and yogurt. In response, Bakery inspected

its facilities and tools for a potential source of the fibers. Bakery concluded

that Silpats, a silicon-based baking pad used to keep the brownies from

sticking to the oven pans, were responsible.

Between October 1 and 6, 1997, Bakery disposed of its entire stock

of Silpats including every Silpat that had been in production the previous

month. Bakery did not mark or in any way take note of the age, number, or

individual condition of any Silpats at that time.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.