Court of Criminal Appeals of Oklahoma November 26, 2003, No. J-2003-594 (F.D.W. v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-11-2003

ACCELERATED DOCKET ORDER

¶ 1 Appellant appeals from an order of the Bryan County District Court, Case No. JDL-2002-56, adjudicating him to be a delinquent child. Appellant alleges the trial court erred in failing to establish the hearsay testimony of the two child witnesses was reliable because the trial court never questioned the witnesses to determine whether they knew right from wrong, or whether they knew the difference between the truth and a lie.

¶ 2 Pursuant to Rule 11.2(A)(1), Rules of the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals, Title 22, Ch. 18, App. (2001), this appeal was automatically assigned to the Accelerated Docket of this Court. The proposition of error was presented in oral argument on September 25, 2003, pursuant to Rule 11.2(F). At the conclusion of oral argument, this Court took the matter under advisement.

¶3 Statements of a child under the age of thirteen relating to physical or sexual abuse against the child are admissible only if it is determined those statements appeared reliable under the circumstances under which they were made, and that the time, content and totality of circumstances surrounding the taking of the statements provide sufficient indicia of reliability so as to render it inherently trustworthy. Matter of A.S., 1989 OK CIV APP 91, 790 P.2d 539, 541; McIntosh v. State, 1991 OK CR 49, 810 P.2d 373, 375; and 12 O.S.2001, § 2803.1(A)(1).

¶ 4 In the case at bar, the child witnesses, although present, were not called to testify either by the State or the defense. In addition, the trial court did not question or meet with the children in a separate hearing. *504However, the statute only requires that a finding be made by the court that the statements appeared reliable under the circumstances under which they were made, and that the time, content and totality of circumstances surrounding the taking of the statement provide sufficient indicia of reliability so as to render them inherently trustworthy.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.