Webster Justice of the Peace Court December 6, 2003 (People v. Sears)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-12-2003
OPINION OF THE COURT
Thomas J. DiSalvo, J.
Facts of the Case
The defendant was charged with common-law driving while *448intoxicated in violation of Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1192 (3) on September 14, 2002 at 12:48 a.m. The defendant was arrested after entering a sobriety checkpoint operated by the Webster Police Department on the eastbound section of New York State Route 104 just prior to the Dewitt Road overpass. A Scott hearing was conducted on June 18, 2003 to determine if the sobriety checkpoint was properly conducted.1 More particularly the defense argues that the location of the sobriety checkpoint was not properly selected. In his memorandum of law defense counsel states that
“Sergeant Small testified that although Webster Police Chief Gerald Pickering authorized the checkpoint, there was no discussion between himself and Chief Pickering as to exactly where the checkpoint would be placed. That was left to the unfettered discretion of Sergeant Small as supervisor of the checkpoint detail.
“Sergeant Small allegedly selected the location according to the Directive,[2] based upon the history of past violations, as well as safety considerations.” (Emphasis taken from defense counsel’s memorandum of law.)
Issues Presented
Must the location of a sobriety checkpoint be based on empirical evidence of prior driving while intoxicated arrests?
Must the location of a sobriety checkpoint be specifically authorized by the chief of police?
Legal Analysis
A. History of Alcohol Related Arrests
In his memorandum of law, Mr. Corletta correctly indicates that the Webster Police Directive issued for September 13, 2002 to September 14, 2002 “states history of past violations was taken into consideration, and Sergeant small also testified as such.” However, a review of said paragraph IV of General Order 504, to which that directive is attached, reads as follows:
“IV Establishing, Cancelling Roadblocks and Checkpoints
*449“A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit