Louisiana Court of Appeal July 2, 2003, Nos. 2002 CA 2021, 2002 CA 2022, 2002 CA 2023 (Mitchell v. Industrial Fill Materials, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-07-2003

J^CIACCIO, J.

Plaintiffs appeal a directed verdict dismissing their workers compensation claim with prejudice.

*38FACTS

Truck driver William Georgetown died when the bed of his dump truck fell and crushed him. There were no witnesses to the accident but Georgetown had just reported to Ronnie Vallery that the bed was not working properly.

The mothers of Georgetown’s three children, Josie Warner, Carolyn Mitchell, and Jocelyn Phillips, filed a disputed claim for Compensation against Terry Vallery Trucking (TVT), Ronnie Vallery Trucking (RVT), and Industrial Fill Materials, Inc. (IFM) and its insurer, Louisiana Workers Compensation Corporation. Plaintiffs alleged that TVT, RVT, and IFM were actually all one company and that Georgetown was killed during the course and scope of his employment with them.

After a hearing, the Office of Workers Compensation (“OWC”) granted a directed verdict holding that: 1) Georgetown was an employee of TVT; 2) plaintiffs failed to prove that Georgetown was an employee of either RVT or IFM; and 3) Georgetown was not within the course and scope of his employment with TVT when the accident occurred. OWC then dismissed plaintiffs’ suit with prejudice.

Plaintiffs now appeal, arguing that the trial court erred: 1) in finding that Georgetown was not acting in the course and scope of his employment when he was killed; and 2) in finding that Georgetown was not employed by RVT and/or IFM at the time of his death.

LAW AND ANALYSIS

Standard of Review

An appellate court’s review of OWC’s factual findings is governed by the manifest error standard.2 An appellate court may set aside OWC’s factual findings only if it determines that the record does not provide a reasonable factual basis for OWC’s conclusion or if, after reviewing the record in its entirety, it concludes that OWC’s finding was clearly wrong.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.