Supreme Court of Connecticut March 11, 2003, SC 16772 (Safford v. Owens Brockway)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-03-2003

Opinion

KATZ, J.

The sole issue in this appeal1 is whether, under General Statutes § 31-308 (b),2 the workers’ com*528pensation review board (board) properly affirmed an award of benefits by the workers’ compensation commissioner for the fourth district (commissioner) that was based solely on medical evidence assessing a permanent impairment rating to a nonscheduled body part. The named defendant,3 Owens Brockway, appeals from the board’s decision affirming an award of workers’ compensation benefits to the plaintiff, Edith Safford. We conclude that the commissioner abused his discretion by awarding benefits on a basis unsupported by medical evidence and, accordingly, we reverse the decision of the board.

The record reveals the following undisputed facts. On September 18, 1997, the plaintiff suffered bilateral rotator cuff tears to her shoulders during the course of her employment with the defendant, which, along with its insurer, AIG Insurance Company, and their third party administrator, GAB Robins Business Services, accepted liability for those injuries through a voluntary agreement. To repair her shoulders, the plaintiff had operations performed by David B. Brown, an orthopedic surgeon, who thereafter issued an opinion that the plaintiff had reached maximum medical improvement and that she had sustained a 20 percent permanent partial disability to each shoulder. Because the shoulder is not a listed body part in the schedule of compensable injuries attached to § 31-308 (b), but the arm or the *529upper extremity is such a listed part, counsel for the defendant wrote to Brown on November 30, 1999, inquiring whether, based on American Medical Association guidelines, the 20 percent rating to the shoulder “should be adjusted to equal a 12 [percent] permanency to the upper extremity or if [Brown stood] by [his] prior rating and instead [felt] that the [plaintiff] suffered a 20 [percent] permanent partial disability to the ‘upper extremity.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.