Connecticut Appellate Court August 19, 2003, AC 22606 (Gallo-Mure v. Tomchik)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-08-2003

Opinion

FLYNN, J.

The defendants, James Tomchik, Maureen Tomchik, Frank Bisecco and Betsy Bisecco, appeal from the trial court’s judgment determining that the plaintiff, Francine M. Gallo-Mure, holds a prescriptive easement over the defendants’ premises. The defen*701dants argue on appeal that the court acted improperly in two ways: (1) its factual finding of “implied consent” in its first articulation was inconsistent with its judgment granting a prescriptive easement; and (2) the court’s finding of continuous use of the property was clearly erroneous in light of the evidence presented that a fence had blocked the plaintiffs access from 1971 through 1986. We are not persuaded by either claim and therefore affirm the judgment of the trial court.

The following facts are relevant to this appeal. The plaintiff has lived on her property at 15 Annawon Avenue in West Haven since May, 1971. The defendants all reside on Ocean Avenue, which runs perpendicular to Annawon Avenue. The Biséceos moved to 185 Ocean Avenue in 1996, and the Tomchiks moved in next door at 183 Ocean Avenue in 1999. These two lots are adjacent to each other and are bordered on the south by Long Island Sound. The defendants share a common driveway that allows them to access Ocean Avenue. This driveway runs behind the rear of the plaintiffs property on Annawon Avenue. The underlying claim ensued when the Tomchiks began constructing a fence that would have blocked the plaintiffs access to the driveway.

The plaintiff claimed that she had prescriptive easement rights to drive on the defendants’ driveway and to park her vehicles on it because she had used the property openly, visibly, continuously and uninterrupted for more than fifteen years under a claim of right. The plaintiff sought and was granted a temporary injunction until such time as the matter could be resolved.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.