Massachusetts Superior Court April 28, 2003, No. ESCR20020647 (Commonwealth v. Delrio)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-04-2003
Agnes, A.J.
This Memorandum of Decision deals with an issue that is common to two otherwise unrelated cases regarding the admissibility of certain out-of-court identifications that were the product of one-on-one show-up procedures arranged by the police, and alleged by the defendants to have been unnecessarily suggestive. In the first case, the defendant, Juan Delrio, is charged by indictment with assault with intent to commit murder and assault and batteiy by means of a dangerous weapon. In the second case, the defendant, Richard Pittman, is charged in an indictment with trafficking in cocaine, a Class B controlled substance, in excess of 14 grams, and other offenses based on information gathered by the Lynn Police Department as a result of a motor vehicle stop.
I. FINDINGS OF FACT IN THE DELRIO CASE
At approximately 9:45 p.m. on the evening of October 22, 2001, Patrick Ruane and Michael Stelenberger drove to 276 Washington Street. This was the home of Paola Pol who was either the current or former girlfriend of their friend Douglas Barrett. Mr. Stelenberger wanted to determine whether Ms. Pol was seeing another man. Mr. Stelenberger knocked on the front door of the large home. Paola’s sister answered the door. There was a heated exchange between her and Mr. Stelenberger. Some male occupants of the home came to the door. A physical confrontation ensued on the front porch. Mr. Ruane, by this time, had joined Mr. Stelenberger on the porch. Mr. Barrett arrived on the porch at some point, and also joined Mr. Stelenberger and Mr. Ruane in the fracas. Mr. Ruane *239ended up in a struggle with an individual later identified as the defendant. At some point during this confrontation, Mr. Ruane felt what appeared to be a painful cramp in his abdomen. He retreated from the porch. He ran as fast as he could away from the scene. When he realized he had been stabbed, he began to search for a telephone. He entered the home of his friend, Douglas Barrett, at 183 Lafayette Street.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit