Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit May 20, 2003, Nos. 02-1127, 02-1128 (J.G. Peta, Inc. v. Club Protector, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-05-2003
BRYSON, Circuit Judge.
Club Protector, Inc., and William T. Held (collectively “Club Protector”) appeal *725from the order of the United States District Court for the Northern District of New York granting the motion of J.G. Peta, Inc., (“Peta”) for summary judgment of noninfringement of U.S. Patent No. 4,830,037 (“the ’037 patent”). We affirm.
I
The ’037 patent relates to a canopy that attaches to the back of a golf cart and covers the compartment that holds golf club bags. The movable canopy can be lowered to protect golf clubs from inclement weather or raised to remove golf clubs from the cart. The canopy attachment includes “frame means adapted to be attached to the golf cart and canopy means movably secured to the frame means.” ’037 patent, col. 1, II. 45-47. Defendant William T. Held owns the ’037 patent and has granted an exclusive license to Club Protector, Inc.
Club Protector sent Peta a cease and desist letter asserting that Peta’s golf cart canopy infringed the claims of the ’037 patent. Peta responded by filing a declaratory judgment action asserting that it did not infringe the ’037 patent and that the patent was invalid. Club Protector then filed a counterclaim of infringement.
After Peta moved for summary judgment of noninfringement, Club Protector sought a continuance pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56(f). The court granted the continuance, extending discovery for 90 days.
At the conclusion of the extended discovery period, Peta renewed its motion for summary judgment. Club Protector opposed the motion for summary judgment and challenged various procedural rulings by a magistrate judge, including the denial of Club Protector’s request to amend its pleadings to add the defenses of equitable estoppel and unclean hands and to take a deposition relating to those defenses.
The district court granted Peta’s motion for summary judgment of noninfringement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit