Navajo Nation Supreme Court August 1, 2003, No. SC-CV-14-03 (Peabody Western Coal Co. v. Navajo Nation Labor Commission)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-08-2003
Opinion delivered by
YAZZIE, Chief Justice.
This case involves a Petition for a Writ of Prohibition by Peabody Western Coal Company (“Peabody”) to prevent the Navajo Nation Labor Commission (“Commission”) from adjudicating a Complaint filed by a former employee of Peabody, Edward Silverhatband (“Silverhatband”). A Writ of Prohibition is an original action in this Court and it “is appropriately issued where the trial court [or quasi-judicial agency] is proceeding without or in excess of its jurisdiction ... and petitioner has no plain, speedy and adequate remedy at law.” Yellowhorse Inc. v. Window Rock Dist. Ct., 5 Nav. R. 85 (Nav. Sup. Ct. 1986).
We hold that the Commission is barred from hearing Silverhatband’s claims under the doctrine of res judicata and therefore grant the Petition for a Writ of Prohibition.
I. FACTS
Silverhatband was employed by Peabody as a Scraper Operator. The terms of his employment were governed by a collective bargaining agreement (“Labor Agreement”) between Peabody and the United Mine Workers of America (“Union”). Peabody issued Silverhatband a Written Notice of Suspension with Intent to Discharge as provided in Article XXI §(b)(c)(d) of the Labor Agreement, on the grounds that Silverhatband showed up to work in an unfit condition. Silverhatband challenged the notice on the grounds that he should not have been terminated for a first offense. He also claimed that he was being treated discriminatorily because other employees who had shown up to work intoxicated had been either sent home to “sleep it off” or had been offered the chance to enter a rehabilitation program.
*317Silverhatband and representatives of Peabody and the Union met to discuss the matter. The parties could not resolve the problem, and Peabody terminated Silverhatband’s employment. Silverhatband and the Union filed a grievance according to the terms of the Labor Agreement. The parties met again to resolve the problem but failed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit