West Virginia Court of Claims April 10, 2003, CC-02-126 (Plock v. Division of Highways)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-04-2003
PER CURIAM:
Claimants brought this action for costs incurred in trimming and topping numerous trees adjacent to their property and U.S. Route 40 in Ohio County. These costs allegedly arise from respondent’s representation that the trees were located on claimants’ property. However, it was later determined that the trees were within *320respondent’s right of way. Respondent was responsible at all times herein for the maintenance of U.S. Route 40 in Ohio County. The Court is of the opinion to deny this claim for the reasons set forth more fully below.
Claimants own real estate adjacent to U.S. Route 40 in Valley Grove, Ohio County which is located near the Pennsylvania State line. Claimants have numerous trees near the edge of their property line adjacent to respondent’s right of way along U.S. Route 40. Their residence is located several yards from the road. The facts and circumstances giving rise to this claim began in May 2001, when an individual was accidentally struck and killed by a vehicle while directing traffic around a tree which had fallen onto U.S. Route 40. This tragic incident occurred near claimants’ property causing them to be concerned about preventing future incidents regarding tree falls. Claimant Douglas Plock called respondent’s Triadelphia office the day after that incident to inquire whether a crew would be coming to the area near their home to remove any dangerous trees near U.S. Route 40. Mr. Plock stated that the individual he spoke to had no information regarding the removal of trees but he was told that the respondent’s right of way was thirteen feet from the edge of the road. Mr. Plock testified that based upon this information he determined that there were numerous trees on his property near U.S. Route 40. He was of the opinion that he was responsible for trimming and cutting some of these trees to protect the traveling public and to avoid potential liability.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit