Richmond County Circuit Court September 23, 2003, Case No. CH03-924 (Fauntleroy v. Borden)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-09-2003
By Judge Melvin R. Hughes, Jr.
This case was tried to the court on September 2, 2003. Upon the completion of all the evidence, the court took the matter under advisement.
In her Bill of Complaint, plaintiff, Shirley Fauntleroy, alleges that her sister, Emily Davis, agreed that, upon her death, Davis would leave Fauntleroy her home if she would move to Richmond to care for Davis in her waning years. She names the executor of Davis’ estate as the defendant and prays, inter alia, that the defendant “specifically perform the agreement entered into by Davis and Fauntleroy by making a good and sufficient deed of the property at 4904 Goddin Court, Richmond, Virginia, to Shirley Fauntleroy.” By Fauntleroy’s testimony and that of the other seven witnesses who testified, Fauntleroy did move to Richmond in 1995, when she took up residence at Davis’ home, remaining there until Davis died in March 2003.
The testimony also revealed that, in August 1995, Davis executed a will wherein she left her entire estate, including her home, to Fauntleroy and Johnny Whiting, Davis and Fauntleroy’s brother. However, upon Davis’ death, her probated will, dated December 1999, specifically revoked the August 1995 will and left the home to the defendant, Celestine Borden, Davis’ step-daughter. The witnesses for both sides agreed that Fauntleroy provided care to Davis but disagreed over the level of care she provided, especially in the later years. The case presents the primary issues of whether any Fauntleroy-Davis parol agreement is enforceable and the admissibility of the decedent’s statements concerning any such agreement.
*145The issue of a parol agreement implicates the statute of frauds. The requirements for the enforceability of a parol agreement are well established in the case law in this Commonwealth. In Wright v. Puckett, 63 Va. (22 Gratt.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit