North Dakota Supreme Court April 17, 2003, 20020177 (Koapke v. Herfendal)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-04-2003
combined-opinion
660 N.W.2d 206 (2003) 2003 ND 64 Vee Ann KOAPKE, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. David A. HERFENDAL, DDS, Defendant and Appellee, and Gerard F. Koorbusch, DDS, MBA, Defendant. No. 20020177. Supreme Court of North Dakota. April 17, 2003. *208 William E. McKechnie, McKechnie Law Office, P.C., Grand Forks, for plaintiff and appellant. Brenda L. Blazer, Vogel Law Firm, Bismarck, for defendant and appellee. SANDSTROM, Justice. [¶ 1] Vee Ann Koapke is appealing from a Northwest Judicial District Court summary judgment dismissing her malpractice claim against a Minot dentist, David Herfendal, for providing her a negligent treatment plan and failing to obtain proper informed consent. We affirm. I [¶ 2] Koapke visited Dr. Herfendal on September 3, 1998, for a cleaning and a checkup because of pain in some of her teeth. Prior to her appointment with Dr. Herfendal, Koapke's last visit to a dentist was in April 1994 when, as best as she can remember, she was diagnosed with gingivitis. Upon Koapke's arrival at Dr. Herfendal's office, her teeth were stained and yellowed from coffee and cigarettes. Koapke testified she generally brushed her teeth once a day and flossed approximately once a month. *209 [¶ 3] Dr. Herfendal testified at his deposition that when Koapke arrived, she was very distraught and emotional and there were tears rolling down her face. Koapke discussed with Dr. Herfendal the pain she was experiencing and the embarrassment she felt about the condition of her mouth. Dr. Herfendal examined Koapke's teeth and gums. He testified he diagnosed Koapke with carious lesions and gave her two treatment options: full extraction of every tooth, or partial extraction, saving only one to three teeth around which partial dentures could be hooked. Koapke testified in her deposition that Dr. Herfendal informed her that her teeth were going to fall out in five years regardless, and explained to her only one option, which was a full-mouth extraction and dentures.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit