Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Lawrence County December 17, 2003, no. 11315 of 2001, C.A. (Estate of Spangler v. Jameson Health System)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-12-2003
PRATT, P.J.,
Plaintiffs have presented a motion to compel responses to second requests for production of documents, and requests the court to compel the defendant, Jameson Health System, to disclose certain statements made by nurses who witnessed and assisted in treating the decedent in the days prior to his death. Defendant Jameson Health System asserts that the statements are protected by the Peer Review Protection Act, 63 PS. §425.1 et seq. and, therefore, are not subject to discovery. In response, plaintiffs argue that the statements fall within the “original source” exception provided by the PRPA, 63 P.S. §425.4, and are discoverable.
Decedent Wilbert E. Spangler Jr. was a patient at Jameson Memorial Hospital for several days in late December 1999, before dying from retroperitoneal bleeding. He had received Heparin, which can cause internal bleeding as a side effect, while being treated at Jameson *131Memorial Hospital before he passed away. Plaintiffs contend that the Heparin was not properly administered and that the defendants did not properly monitor the decedent for adverse side effects.
Defendant Jameson’s attorney informed plaintiffs’ attorney that three of the treating nurses had prepared written statements. These statements are the subject of plaintiffs’ instant motion. However, none of the parties provided the court with descriptions of the statements, the identity of the nurses who prepared them, or the circumstances under which the statements were prepared.
DISCUSSION
Section 425.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit