Court of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee July 9, 2004, M2002-02375-CCA-R3-CD (State of Tennessee v. Andrew Neal Davis - Concurring)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-07-2004

IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TENNESSEE

AT NASHVILLE

STATE OF TENNESSEE v. ANDREW NEAL DAVIS

Criminal Court for Davidson County

No. 2001-A-391

No. M2002-02375-CCA-R3-CD Filed July 9, 2004

JOHN EVERETT WILLIAMS, J., separate concurring opinion.

I concur in the results reached by the lead opinion but write separately to amplify some of

my concerns. The prosecution has placed the conviction for aggravated child abuse of a child under

the age of six in peril through mistakes, inadvertence, or neglect. There exists no evidence of

intentional misconduct on the part of the District Attorney General’s office. I hasten to add that this

District Attorney General’s office is not an abuser of the power or processes used to prosecute crimes

in its jurisdiction. Although I have voted to affirm this conviction, I feel I must add a word of

warning to others who may wish to rely upon my decision. At first glance, the practice of amending

an indictment without the defendant’s consent at such a late date is looked upon with disfavor. The

practice suggests that someone was inattentive to the process and comes dangerously close to

violating principles of fundamental fairness. It is akin to changing the rules in the middle of the

game, a game which is played by professionals in which inches determine the winner and loser. This

competent defense counsel did not appear shaken or surprised by the State’s amendment. Indeed,

I have determined trial counsel’s trial strategy was not changed in the least. That is the main reason

I have chosen to affirm this conviction. However, I am mindful of the time trial counsel takes in

explaining to a client what has just transpired in court. Imagine explaining to a client that after being

put to trial once on what was a Class B felony, the client is now facing a Class A felony with a

potential for greater punishment. This could have taken away valuable time which counsel could

have used to ready for the trial which was about to begin moments later.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.