Supreme Court of Georgia October 12, 2004, S04A1386 (Smith v. Jones)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-10-2004

HUNSTEIN, Justice.

The Taylor County Board of Education conveyed a school building to the Mauk-Charing-Norwich Community Club in 1956 while retaining a reversionary interest in the property. In 1970 the Club obtained ownership of all rights in the school building when the Board quit claimed to it the entire property, including the reversionary interest. However, in 2002 the Board conveyed its purported reversionary interest in the school building to Michelle Smith. The Club, through its officers, brought a declaratory judgment action and sought injunctive relief. Smith answered and counterclaimed for defamation and RICO violations predicated upon alleged acts of burglary, conspiracy and arson. The trial court granted summary judgment in favor of the Club and Smith appeals.

1. Smith does not challenge the trial court’s determination that the Club is the owner of the school property. Rather, in her sole enumeration of error regarding that property, Smith contends that a quiet title action, not a declaratory judgment action, was the proper

*662

procedural vehicle to resolve the parties’ dispute and that the Club’s action should be dismissed for failure to utilize the quiet title procedure, citing

Porter v. Houghton,

273 Ga. 407 (542 SE2d 491) (2001). However, that case merely stands for the proposition that declaratory judgment is not available to a party seeking to resolve potentially adverse claims to land when that party cannot show that he needs direction in order to handle an existing controversy.

1

As the trial court correctly noted, “[djisputes concerning ownership of or right of access to land are classic candidates for resolution via declaratory judgment. [Cits.]”

J. M. Huber Corp. v. Ga. Marble Co.,

239 Ga. App. 271, 273 (1) (520 SE2d 296) (1999).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.