Supreme Court of Georgia September 27, 2004, S04A0944 (McClure v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-09-2004

Sears, Presiding Justice.

Appellant Samuel McClure appeals his convictions for felony murder and aggravated assault.

1

Having reviewed the record, we conclude the trial court abused its discretion by admitting into evidence a photograph of the victim’s corpse after internal organs had been removed for donation. In light of the overwhelming evidence of appellant’s guilt, however, we find this error to be harmless. Appellant’s remaining claims of error being without merit, we affirm.

Construed most favorably to the verdicts, the evidence of record shows that appellant was riding in a car with Youngker and the victim, Walker. The victim had agreed to lend money to appellant. The threesome drove to an apartment complex where an acquaintance, Boaz, lived. Youngker exited the car and called Boaz on his cell phone, leaving appellant standing beside the car with the victim inside. Youngker then saw appellant shoot the victim in the head. Youngker began to run away and realized that appellant had shot him, too. Appellant caught up with Youngker, struck him and put a gun to his head, but it misfired. As Youngker ran off again, he was shot a second time. Appellant then left the scene and Youngker returned to the car and waited for police. The victim later died.

At trial, residents of the apartment complex testified that they heard both a gunshot and a voice demanding money. Boaz testified that while on the phone with Youngker, he heard scuffling, a loud noise and a demand for money. At trial, appellant claimed that Youngker had pointed a gun at him and tried to rob him. Appellant claimed that when he attempted to grab the gun, it fired accidentally, injured Youngker, and killed the victim.

1. Construed most favorably to the verdicts, the evidence of record was sufficient to enable rational triers of fact to find appellant guilty of felony murder and aggravated assault.

2

Appellant urges that Youngker’s testimony at trial was not credible.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.