Court of Appeals of South Carolina March 8, 2004, 373 (Deloitte & Touche, LLP v. Unisys Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-03-2004

BEATTY, J.:

Deloitte & Touche, L.L.P. appeals a circuit court order denying its motion seeking arbitration. We affirm.

FACTS

In 1996, Deloitte commenced an action against Unisys Corporation based on a contractual dispute. Unisys then gave notice of and filed a demand for arbitration. Unisys also subsequently moved to have the case dismissed under Rules 12(b)(1) and 12(b)(8), SCRCP. At the time, Deloitte was opposed to arbitration and argued against Unisys’s arbitration demand. The circuit court held that Deloitte could not be forced to arbitrate its claims against Unisys, reasoning that the arbitration provision of the contract under which Unisys made its request was unenforceable under South Carolina law and incapable of being “rescued” by the Federal Arbitration Act.

1

Unisys appealed the ruling, but the appeal was dismissed as being interlocutory and premature.

Following the dismissal of the appeal, the parties resumed litigation. That process has lasted for nearly five and one-half

*182

years. The discovery phase has generated thousands of documents and numerous motions and hearings. A three-day “Phase I” bench trial was conducted, where Deloitte was allowed to present one of its claims.

2

The trial judge ruled in favor of Unisys. Deloitte then moved for arbitration in August 2002, shortly before Unisys was to present its counterclaims in “Phase II” of the trial. Deloitte asserted that it could “join” Unisys in “voluntary arbitration” since Unisys had continued to maintain an open file with the American Arbitration Association even after its demand for arbitration was denied.

The trial judge denied Deloitte’s motion for arbitration on August 15, 2002. He found Deloitte’s motion to be duplicative of Unisys’s 1997 motion to compel arbitration. The trial judge reasoned that Deloitte, having successfully contested Unisys’s motion nearly six years earlier, could not now argue in favor of arbitration.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.