Court of Appeals of North Carolina April 6, 2004, COA03-562 (Marketplace Antique Mall, Inc. v. Lewis)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-04-2004
BRYANT, Judge.
Marketplace Antique Mall, Inc., D.G. Samuel, Jr. (Samuel), individually, and D.G. Samuel, Jr., d/b/a Queen Street Antiques (collectively plaintiffs) appeal a judgment filed 31 October 2002 dismissing plaintiffs’ action with prejudice and awarding damages on defendant Steven M. Lewis’ counterclaim for constructive fraud and breach of contract.
1
With respect to his counterclaim, defendant presented evidence at trial establishing that Samuel and he had been iife partners who had joined as equal partners in a business venture restoring and selling antique furniture. Defendant had some experience in this field because his family had worked in the antique business. Samuel and defendant opened and operated two stores: Queen Street Antiques and Marketplace Antique Mall. As to Marketplace Antique Mall, defendant testified and the documentary evidence showed that Samuel and defendant signed the lease for the premises “as business partners.” In addition, they “filed for a partnership tax number” for the business and submitted their “income tax returns at the end of the year as partners.” As to Queen Street Antiques, defendant acknowledged that, for tax purposes, the business was classified as a sole proprietorship run by Samuel. However, he explained the set up was an initial arrangement in order to expedite assignment of the tax number required to operate the business in a booth at an antique mall. Tax numbers for sole proprietorships were issued on the spot whereas a
*598
partnership tax number could take up to six weeks to be issued. Defendant testified the intent was to get into the booth right away by registering as a sole proprietorship and then to “come back to the tax office and change [the classification] immediately to a partnership.” The partnership tax number, however, never came into effect because Samuel did not apply for a change in classification.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit