Court of Appeals of Texas August 19, 2004, 2-03-174-CR (Hudson v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-08-2004
OPINION
TERRIE LIVINGSTON, Justice.
Robert Willard Hudson, Jr. appeals his conviction for assault causing bodily injury. After a jury trial, the trial court sentenced him to ninety days’ confinement and a $1,500 fine.
On appeal, Hudson raises five points that generally challenge the trial court’s failure to submit to the jury an instruction on the law of defense of property and its imposition of an enhanced sentence because notice of enhancement was untimely. Because we determine that Hudson was not entitled to an instruction on defense of property at trial, we affirm his conviction. However, because we also determine that Hudson was harmed by the State’s failure to provide timely notice of enhancement, we reverse the trial court’s judgment on punishment and remand for a new punishment trial.
BACKGROUND FACTS
On May 7, 2002, Ricky Robles, a roofing superintendent, drove through a parking lot en route to a job site in Flower Mound. The parking lot was between a swimming pool under construction and a model home. Hudson was the supervisor of the construction site where the swimming pool was being built. As Robles drove through the parking lot, Hudson waved him down. Hudson told Robles that he could not drive through the parking lot. When Robles asked why, Hudson said, “Because I said so.” Hudson further told Robles that he was the owner of the property. Robles said, “You’re not the owner” and attempted to roll up his window and leave. Testimony differed as to whether Hudson then pulled Robles from his truck or whether Robles jumped out and attacked Hudson.
When police arrived, Hudson told Flower Mound police officer Ronnie Madeiros that Robles got belligerent, cursed at Hudson, grabbed and threw Hudson’s cell phone, then jumped out of his truck and attacked Hudson. According to Robles, Hudson opened Robles’s passenger door, grabbed Robles by his shirt, neck, and hair, and dragged Robles out of his truck.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit