Missouri Court of Appeals December 21, 2004, ED 84229 (Hanna v. Darr)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-12-2004

WILLIAM H. CRANDALL, JR., Judge.

Plaintiffs, John E. Hanna and John E. Hanna Oldsmobile, Inc., appeal from the trial court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of defendants, Donald Darr and Don Darr Pontiac, Inc., d/b/a Don Darr Chevrolet, in a breach of contract action. We reverse and remand.

The evidence established that in December 1997, Hanna and Darr

1

entered into an oral agreement to own and operate a Chevrolet dealership jointly, with Darr owning a 55 percent interest and Hanna owning a 45 percent interest. They also entered into an agreement to purchase property on which to operate them dealership. Both parties previously owned car dealerships which they were selling. The purchase of the property for the new dealership resulted in tax benefits to Hanna. In February 1998, the parties incorporated Darr-Hanna Chevrolet, Inc. in Missouri. In May 1998, Darr alone acquired a franchise for a Chevrolet dealership from General Motors and operated the dealership as Don Darr Chevrolet (hereinafter “the dealership”). He also leased the property that he and Hanna originally agreed to purchase. Hanna had no ownership interest in the dealership.

In June 2001, Hanna brought the present action against Darr for breach of contract. In his petition, he alleged that Darr breached the agreement with him to own and operate the dealership jointly and to purchase property on which to operate the dealership. He sought damages as follows: (1) for his expenses associated with starting up the dealership, including those for the purchase of the property on which to locate the dealership, totaling $57,082.14; (2) for his income tax liabili

*4

ties of $111,152.13 incurred because he did not reinvest the money obtained from the sale of his previously-owned car dealership; (3) for his lost salary of $11,000.00 per month; and (4) for his “lost profits.” In June 2003, Hanna amended his petition to include as damages “the loss of [his] percentage of the value of the Chevrolet franchise.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.