Court of Appeals of Texas April 8, 2004, 2-03-002-CV (Warrantech Corp. v. Computer Adapters Services, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-04-2004
OPINION
JOHN CAYCE, Chief Justice.
I. Introduction
Warrantech Corporation (Warrantech) and Warrantech Consumer Products Services, Inc. (WCPS) (collectively, the War-rantech Parties) appeal from the trial court’s judgment in favor of Computer Adapters Services, Inc. d/b/a Computer Accessories Services (CAS), Lou Braun, and Victoria Clyde. The primary issue we must decide is whether the trial court abused its discretion by excluding, based on the attorney-client privilege, a letter from Clyde to her attorney that showed
*521
some of Clyde’s trial testimony to be false. Because we conclude that the trial court did not abuse its discretion by excluding the letter and that the ruling, even if erroneous, would not have caused the rendition of an improper judgment, and because the Warranteeh Parties do not prevail on their remaining appellate issues, we will affirm.
II. Background Facts and Procedural History
Warranteeh provides service contracts to businesses that sell computers and related equipment. Pursuant to these contracts, product purchasers may obtain warranty services in the event they encounter problems with the products. Warranted! provides its service contract services via Warranteeh Help Desk, Inc./ WCPS.
1
Thus, if a customer has a problem with a computer and calls the number provided on the service contract, the customer will reach WCPS. WCPS attempts to diagnose and solve the problem over the phone, but if that proves unsuccessful, WCPS refers the customer to a repair company, which performs repair services on the computer and bills WCPS for the work. During the time when most of the events relevant to this case occurred, WCPS used hundi'eds of repair companies.
Braun and Clyde are husband and wife. From April through August 1997, Braun, and occasionally Clyde, performed consulting work for Warranteeh on a contract basis. In 1997, Warranteeh hired Braun as a full-time employee, as Vice President of Operations for WCPS.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit