Missouri Court of Appeals March 30, 2004, WD 62799 (Azbill v. UMB Scout Brokerage Services, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-2004

VICTOR C. HOWARD, Presiding Judge.

Dianna Azbill appeals from the trial court’s order granting UMB Scout Brokerage’s (UMB) motion to dismiss Azbill’s first amended petition. The trial court dismissed Azbill’s petition and found that arbitration was not needed, because Azbill would have no standing, in that decedent’s estate, not Azbill, was named the primary beneficiary of the individual retirement account (IRA). In her first point, Azbill claims the trial court erred in granting UMB’s motion to dismiss, because the beneficiary form with Azbill’s name listed was ambiguous on its face. The court, therefore, erred when it failed to consider extrinsic evidence to resolve the ambiguity. Azbill asserts that decedent named her on the beneficiary form and that extrinsic evidence established that decedent intended to make Azbill his primary beneficiary, not his estate. Secondly, Azbill argues the trial court erred in granting UMB’s motion to dismiss, because as a matter of law, a court, and not an arbitrator, determines the existence of a contractual relationship by applying state law principles. Consequently, the court erred when it concluded that if the parties entered arbitration, it would be outside the parameters of the court case.

We reverse and remand to the trial court for entry of an order compelling the parties to proceed with arbitration.

Background

Lloyd Lee Hatfield (decedent) established an IRA account with UMB on or about May 10, 1999. When he established the account, he completed a “Brokerage IRA Application,” in which he agreed as follows:

I agree that all controversies that may arise between us concerning any order or transaction, or the continuation, performance or breach of this or any other agreement between us, whether entered into before, on, or after the date this account is opened, shall be determined by arbitration before a panel of independent arbitrators set up by either the New York Stock Exchange, Inc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.