District Court of Appeal of Florida February 11, 2004, 3D02-3321 (G & G Fashion Design, Inc. v. Garcia)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-02-2004
870 So.2d 870 (2004) G & G FASHION DESIGN, INC., Lisbet M. Ghilardi and William F. Younkin, Appellants, v. Enrique GARCIA, Appellee. No. 3D02-3321. District Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District. February 11, 2004. Rehearing and/or Clarification Denied April 21, 2004. *871 Francine D. Holbrook, for appellants. Dennis B. Freeman, Miami, for appellee. Before SCHWARTZ, C.J., COPE, and WELLS, JJ. WELLS, Judge. Shareholders Lisbet Ghilardi and William Younkin appeal from a final judgment valuing shareholder Enrique Garcia's interest in a closely held corporation at $150,000. We affirm. Enrique Garcia is a fifty per cent owner of G & G Fashion Design, Inc., a corporation that operates two clothing stores-Flash Swimwear and Flash Lingerieat the Bal Harbour Shops in Miami Beach. Lisbet Ghilardi and her husband, William Younkin, own the remaining fifty percent interest in G & G. In March 2001, Garcia brought suit to dissolve G & G. Ghilardi and Younkin, pursuant to section 607.1436 of the Florida Statutes, elected to purchase Garcia's fifty per cent interest in the corporation. Because the parties could not agree on the value of Garcia's shares, the trial court was obligated to "determine the fair value of the petitioner's shares as of the day before the date on which the petition [to dissolve the corporation] was filed...." § 607.1436(4), Fla. Stat. (2003). During a five-day bench trial, the lower court heard conflicting evidence on valuing the shares of this closely held corporation. Ghilardi and Younkin presented testimony that the fair value of Garcia's shares of this on-going business should be zero based on the investment value method. Garcia presented evidence that his shares were worth $150,000 based on the market value method. The trial court adopted the market value method and valued Garcia's shares at $150,000. Section 607.1436(4) and Florida case law neither define "fair value" nor provide criteria by which "fair value" may be measured.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit