Supreme Court of Iowa January 22, 2004, 02-0624 (Johnson v. American Family Mutual Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-01-2004

CARTER, Justice.

Plaintiff, Stephen Johnson, who is suing as the assignee of Eric Jennings, an individual found liable for damages in excess of his liability insurance policy limits in automobile personal-injury litigation, appeals from an adverse judgment in a bad-faith action against Jennings’ insurer, American Family Mutual Insurance Company (American Family). As grounds for reversal, the plaintiff urges that the district court improperly (1) instructed that as a requirement for recovery in this bad-faith litigation the plaintiff must show that the insurer had no reasonable basis for refusing to pay its policy limit, (2) allowed expert witnesses to testify with respect to the bad-faith issues, and (3) admitted evidence of plaintiffs medical history that tended to contradict the jury’s verdict in the personal-injury litigation. We separately consider these contentions and find them to be without merit. We affirm the judgment of the district court.

On January 29, 1996, an automobile accident occurred between the plaintiff and Jennings. American Family provided liability insurance coverage for Jennings up to a limit of $100,000 per claimant. It wrote to Jennings informing him that it had retained counsel on his behalf. That communication advised Jennings- of the $100,000 policy limit applicable to the claim and that he would be personally liable for any judgment in excess of that amount. The letter stated that conflict-of-interest problems might arise between his interests and those of American Family and invited him to obtain his own counsel.

The litigation was handled on Jennings’ behalf by attorneys John Stonebraker and Pat Woodward retained by American Family. It was apparent from the outset that the accident had been solely the fault of Jennings and that he had no basis for disputing liability. Discovery disclosed that plaintiff claimed to have developed a disease known as Fibromyalgia as a result of the accident.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.