Court of Appeals of Minnesota February 10, 2004, A03-1443 (Fay v. St. Louis County Board of Commissioners)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-02-2004
OPINION
TOUSSAINT, Chief Judge.
On appeal from the district court’s invalidation of the county board’s redistricting plan and subsequent appointment of a redistricting commission, appellant county board argues that a redistricting plan with a ten-percent-or-less-population deviation among districts is prima facie valid and may be implemented with no justification by the board. Because we find no error in the district court’s findings and conclusion that the board failed to satisfy the standards of the Minnesota county-redistricting statute, we affirm the court’s determination that the plan is invalid and a redistricting commission was required.
FACTS
Appellant St. Louis County Board of Commissioners (the board) is composed of seven commissioners, each representing one district. Respondent Joanne Fay is one of those commissioners. After the 2000 Federal Census showed a St. Louis County population of 200,528, the parties agreed that redistricting was necessary.
The board considered several proposed redistricting schemes. Pursuant to published notice, a public hearing was held on May 21, 2002. At the public hearing, the county auditor submitted three plans and a commissioner submitted two alternatives. The board then discussed the plans and referred three plans, Plan A, Alternate 1, and Alternate 2, to the next board meeting for final resolution. The minutes reflect that on May 28, the board, the auditor, and a resident addressed the plans. After motions to adopt Plan A failed and Alternate 2 died without support, Alternate 1 was adopted with two dissenters, Commissioners Fink and Fay.
On Juné 4, Commissioner Fay petitioned for a writ of mandamus. She claimed that adoption of Alternate 1 “was effected by the [board] without applying or adhering to the standards and criteria set forth in Minn.Stat. § 375.025, subd. 1,” specifically that (1) the population deviation exceeded ten percent and (2) the districts were not “as. nearly equal in population as possible.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit