Appellate Court of Illinois January 16, 2004, 1-03-0795 (Thomas v. Fuerst)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-01-2004

JUSTICE O’BRIEN

delivered the opinion of the court:

Plaintiff, Aaron Thomas, a member of an Orthodox Jewish community, filed a second amended complaint against defendants Rabbi Shmuel Fuerst, Rabbi Yosef Wainkrantz, Rabbi Chaim Goldzweig (collectively referred to as the Rabbinic Court), and Danny Shabat, claiming the Rabbinic Court had excommunicated plaintiff from the Jewish community in order to punish him for initiating a civil action against Shabat. Plaintiff alleged, by excommunicating him, the Rabbinic Court committed libel, violated his right to due process, intentionally inflicted emotional distress, and engaged in a conspiracy with Shabat. The circuit court dismissed plaintiffs second amended complaint pursuant to section 2 — 619.1 of the Illinois Code of Civil Procedure (the Code) (735 ILCS 5/2 — 619.1 (West 2000)). Plaintiff appeals, claiming the circuit court erred in dismissing his second amended complaint, as each count in the complaint states a cause of action. We affirm.

In his second amended complaint, plaintiff pleaded that he lives “in a strict orthodox Jewish community and culture wherein observance of Jewish law is universal, and wherein such observance is a prerequisite for normal societal relations and normal economic activity.” The Rabbinic Court, also referred to as a Beit Din, is responsible for administering proper law and order within the orthodox Jewish community.

Plaintiff pleaded that from 1998-2001, he prosecuted a civil complaint in the Cook County circuit court against Shabat and his wife for their “sexual exploitation” of plaintiffs minor son. During February 2001, Shabat asked Rabbi Fuerst to use his position as head of the Rabbinic Court to “neutralize” plaintiffs lawsuit against the Shabats.

Plaintiff pleaded that in February, May, and July 2001, he received three summons to appear before the Rabbinic Court to “justify” his civil lawsuit against the Shabats.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.