United States Bankruptcy Court, E.D. Wisconsin June 18, 2004, 19-21642 (In Re Howard)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-06-2004

MEMORANDUM DECISION

SUSAN V. KELLEY, Bankruptcy Judge.

The Debtors moved to voluntarily dismiss their chapter 13 case, and indicated that they intended to immediately re-file a chapter 7 petition to discharge medical bills incurred during the chapter 13 case.

1

The Debtors filed this motion despite the provisions of Bankruptcy Code § 109(g)(2), which states that no individual may file a bankruptcy petition within 180 days of a prior bankruptcy case if “the debtor requested and obtained the voluntary dismissal of the case following the filing of a request for relief from the automatic stay provided by section 362 of this title.” The Debtors’ mortgagee filed a motion for relief from stay in September 2003, but the Debtors resolved the motion by paying over $2,000 in post-petition arrearages directly to the creditor. According to their motion, as a result of illness and injury, Mr. Howard no longer can work. The Debtors therefore wish to surrender their house to the mortgagee, and obtain the chapter 7 discharge of the medical .bills and any deficiency that will be due under the mortgage. The chapter 13 trustee objected, not to the dismissal, but to the “abrogation of 11 U.S.C. § 109(g)(2).”

Courts are split on whether the provisions of § 109(g)(2) are mandatory or discretionary. The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals has not addressed this issue, nor has there been a reported case from any bankruptcy court in the Seventh Circuit. The trustee cites

In re Stuart,

297 B.R. 665, 668 (Bankr.S.D.Ga.2003), which held that the 180-day bar of § 109(g)(2) is mandatory, and the Debtors should not be permitted to re-file prior to the bar date, even if the new filing would not constitute an abuse of the Bankruptcy Code.

2

Stuart

is among several courts that have found the language of § 109(g)(2) unambiguous; these courts accordingly apply the “plain meaning rule” as dictated by the Supreme Court.

E.g., Hartford Underwriters Insurance Co. v. Union Planters Bank,

530 U.S. 1, 6, 120 S.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.