Court of Appeals of Iowa May 14, 2004, 02-1691 (Stewart v. Stewart)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-05-2004

ZIMMER, J.

Plaintiff Leanne Stewart appeals following the district court’s entry of a “Protective Order by Consent Agreement.” She contends the consent order is invalid because she did not agree to its entry. She also contends the court erred when it denied her request to offer evidence in support of her petition for relief from domestic abuse, and in failing to make a finding regarding the issue of domestic abuse. Because we conclude the protective order was not entered in compliance with Iowa Code chapter 236 (2001), we vacate the order and remand this matter to the district court for further proceedings.

Leann filed a chapter 236 petition for relief from domestic abuse. In her petition, she alleged her husband, Scott Stewart, threw a water pitcher at her while she was in bed, kicked her out of bed, dragged her outside in her underwear, slammed her against a brick pillar, and locked her out of the parties’ marital home. She alleged her husband broke her glasses and that his

*117

actions caused bruising and fabric burns on her body. After reviewing the petition, a district court judge entered a temporary protective order, and set a hearing to determine if the order should be made permanent.

See

Iowa Code §§ 236.3, .4.

The matter came on for hearing before the Honorable John Bauercamper. The parties appeared personally and were represented by counsel. Before any evidence was taken, the court asked whether the parties would be willing to enter into a consent decree. Scott stated he was willing to enter into a consent agreement, but Leann rejected that option.

After Leann rejected the entry of a protective order by consent agreement the district court stated,

I do believe that a party can ask for a Consent Decree on the no contact and abuse provision of the Order without consent of the other party and without agreement on collateral issues like child custody, and child support, and other collateral issues of that sort.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.