Indiana Court of Appeals June 11, 2004, 88A01-0309-CR-330 (Pagan v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-06-2004

OPINION

BARNES, Judge.

Case Summary

Angel Pagan appeals his conviction and sentence for Class B felony robbery. We affirm in part and remand in part.

*918

Issues

We restate the issues before us as:

I. whether the State presented sufficient evidence to convict Pagan of robbery as charged in the information;

II. whether he is entitled to a new trial because of an unauthorized separation of the jurors during deliberations;

III. whether his trial counsel was ineffective; and

IV. whether his sentence is inappropriate.

Facts

The facts most favorable to the judgment are that on October 8, 2002, Pagan entered Hardinsburg Video by himself, pointed a knife at Jody Melntyre, and demanded that she give him all of the money in the store's cash register and a moneybag under the counter. Hardins-burg Video appears to be a sole proprietorship owned and operated by Melntyre. After obtaining the money, Pagan ordered Meclntyre to lie down in an adjoining room and, before leaving, threatened to kill her if she got up in the next two minutes. Pagan took none of MelIntyre's personal property. Police apprehended Pagan and two companions, Angel Torres and James Thompson, shortly thereafter. Pagan then gave a recorded statement to police admitting to the crime, but claiming it was Torres' and Thompson's idea to commit the robbery.

The State charged Pagan with one count of robbery with a deadly weapon, a Class B felony. The information, as amended, specifically alleged that Pagan took property "from another person, to-wit: Har-dinsburg Video, owned by Jody Melntyre ...." App. p. 29. After a jury trial on March 4 through 7, 2003, Pagan was found guilty as charged. Before sentencing, Pagan filed a motion alleging that at least two jurors committed misconduct by making cell phone calls during deliberations without the knowledge of the parties or court authorization. Nevertheless, the trial court proceeded to sentencing over Pagan's objection.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.