Supreme Court of Iowa October 6, 2004, 03-0552 (Worth County Friends of Agriculture v. Worth County)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-10-2004

CADY, Justice.

Worth County and the Worth County Board of Supervisors, collectively referred to as “the County,” appeal from a district court order declaring the County Rural Health and Family Farm Protection Ordinance to be void and unenforceable. On our review, we affirm the judgment of the district court.

I. Background Facts and Proceedings

Iowa is largely defined by its proud and rich agricultural economy. Approximately ninety percent of the land within its borders is devoted to agriculture, and the presence of agriculture in Iowa not only profoundly impacts all its residents, but, literally, the world beyond.

1

While agriculture has been woven into the very fabric of this state over each passing generation, one segment of this

*260

fertile heritage has been the subject of difficult debate and discourse within the last decade. This debate centers on livestock confinement operations, particularly hog confinements. The strength and longevity of the debate directly relates to the corresponding increase in the number and size of hog confinement operations in Iowa.

2

Pork is a multibillion-dollar Iowa industry and now employs nearly 100,000 people.

3

While the impact of hog production on the Iowa economy is substantial, its recent growth has engendered many concerns over its impact on the environment, the health of its workers, and the quality of life of nearby residents and Iowans in general. Large confinements generate a staggering amount of animal waste, which gives rise to legitimate concerns about air quality and contamination of lakes and streams, as well as underground water.

4

As a result of these concerns, and others, Worth County, located in north-central Iowa, enacted a county ordinance in 2001 called the “Rural Health and Family Farm Protection Ordinance.” The ordinance was the thoughtful product of the cumulative work of the Worth County Board of Health, a citizen advisory committee, and the Board of Supervisors.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.