Texas Court of Appeals, 3rd District (Austin) September 23, 2004, 03-03-00434-CV (Perdue v. Patten Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-09-2004

OPINION

BEA ANN SMITH, Justice.

The trial court granted a no-evidence summary judgment denying a bill of review, then attempted to grant a new trial vacating its summary judgment. Two issues are presented: whether a new trial was timely granted while the court still had plenary jurisdiction, and if not, whether there is any evidence to support the necessary elements of a bill of review. We hold that the new-trial order was null and void, so the summary judgment is properly before us on appeal. Because the summary-judgment evidence raises a fact issue on each element of the bill of review, we reverse and remand this cause to the trial court.

BACKGROUND

In 1991, Matthew Perdue and his mother, Thelma Cade-Perdue (collectively the Perdues), each bought an undeveloped lot in a subdivision developed by Patten Corporation and Southwest Patten Corporation (collectively, Patten). The Perdues assert that before the sale and in the purchase contracts Patten represented that the lots were buildable and had available potable water. When these representations proved to be untrue, the Perdues filed suit against Patten in 1995, alleging breach of contract, violations of the deceptive trade practices act, and fraud.

1

About a year after they filed suit, their attorney Michael Kuehr was called for army reserve duty; he filed a motion to withdraw as the Perdues’ counsel and substituted attorneys L. Lashelle Wilson and David Bosworth, who shared the same address.

When the court placed the cases on the dismissal docket in July 1998, it sent a

*600

notice of the “drop docket” to Patten’s attorney and Kuehr — but not to Wilson or Bosworth; the cases were to be dismissed if no party appeared on August 31, 1998. When the Perdues failed to appear, the court signed an order dismissing their causes. The Perdues did not find but about the dismissal until the spring of 1999. In July 1999, Wilson filed a petition for bill of review on behalf of the Perdues.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.