California Court of Appeal October 13, 2004, F044983 (MENEES v. Andrews)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-10-2004

Opinion

DAWSON, J.

This is an appeal from that portion of a judgment which awarded to respondent Todd Andrews, M.D. (Dr. Andrews), costs in the amount of $27,212.38 to reimburse him for expert witness fees. The trial court awarded these costs on the basis of Code of Civil Procedure section 998 (section 998), which provides in subdivision (c)(1); “If an offer made by a defendant is not accepted and the plaintiff fails to obtain a more favorable judgment. . ., the court. . ., in its discretion, may require the plaintiff to pay a reasonable sum to cover costs of the services of expert witnesses . . . actually incurred and reasonably necessary in either, or both, preparation for trial. . . , or during trial. . . , of the case by the defendant.”

Appellants Robert Menees and Lisa Menees contend the trial court erred, because the section 998 offer to compromise was not unconditional. We agree.

BACKGROUND

Dr. Andrews was appellant Lisa Menees’s treating obstetrician/gynecologist at the birth of twin babies in September 2001. The first of the infants to be bom suffered injuries from falling to the floor during the course of his delivery. Appellants, his mother and father, jointly sued Dr. Andrews and Bakersfield Memorial Hospital, the hospital at which the delivery occurred.

1

The complaint stated two causes of action: one in favor of Lisa Menees for medical malpractice and another in favor of Robert Menees for negligent infliction of emotional distress. In September 2003, Dr. Andrews made a written offer to compromise pursuant to section 998 which read as follows:

*1543

“TO: PLAINTIFFS, ROBERT AND LISA MENEES AND TO THEIR ATTORNEY OF RECORD:

“Pursuant to Section 998 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Defendant TODD ANDREWS, M.D., hereby offers to settle and dismiss the above-entitled action in its entirety for a waiver of costs, each party to bear its own costs and attorney’s fees, and to allow judgment to be entered in accord herewith.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.