District Court, D. Kansas January 23, 2004, 03-4087-RDR (Wisdom v. SAINT PAUL FIRE AND MARINE INS. CO.)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-01-2004

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

ROGERS, District Judge.

This is a declaratory judgment action. Plaintiff asserts that defendant had a duty

*1236

to defend and indemnify plaintiff in a lawsuit pursued against plaintiff by Devyn Falcon. This case is now before the court upon defendant’s summary judgment motion.

Facts accepted for the purposes of this order

The following facts appear to be uncon-troverted for the purposes of the instant motion only. Plaintiff Eric Wisdom is a dentist in Manhattan, Kansas who has practiced since 1975. Devyn Falcon worked for Wisdom as a dental assistant starting in early September 2000 and was twenty years old during the events in question.

Falcon filed a lawsuit against Wisdom which included the following allegations. Wisdom told Falcon that she would be a good person to help him with TMJ treatments. TMJ is a pain syndrome involving the temporomandibular joint. He told her that he needed a mature assistant since in some cases the patient would be required to remove his or her shirt. He said that this position would require extra training and that she would be paid more once the training was complete. Falcon ultimately agreed to the training so that she could become Wisdom’s special assistant to work with TMJ patients. To conduct the training, Wisdom and Falcon arranged to meet on October 13, 2000 at an office in Chapman, Kansas which Wisdom had not used the previous six months. Falcon had not been to Chapman before. Wisdom said he chose this site because other staff members might be jealous if they learned he was providing this training to Falcon.

Wisdom had been trained in the use of an Alpha-Stim 100 micro TENS unit. He had used the unit on half a dozen patients. It can be used for TMJ. TMJ may require treatment with the unit over the entire body. Falcon has TMJ pain, and Wisdom was aware of this prior to the day in question.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.