District Court, S.D. New York August 26, 2004, 03 CIV. 8695(RCC) (National Abortion Federation v. Ashcroft)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-08-2004

OPINION & ORDER

CASEY, District Judge.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

I.BACKGROUND.439

A. The Act.439

B. Procedural History of This Case.441

C. The Congressional Record .443

1. 104th Congress .443

(a) June 1995 House

Hearing.443

(b) November 1995 Senate

Hearing.444

(c) March 1996 House

Hearing.445

2. 105th Congress.445

3. 106th Congress .446

4. 107th Congress.446

5. 108th Congress .448

6. Views of Advocacy and Medical Associations.449

(a) Associations Opposing the

Act.449

(b) Associations Supporting the

Act.452

(c) The American Medical Association

.452

D. Stenberg v. Carhart.452

1. The Nebraska Statute.453

2. The Majority Opinion.453

*439

(a) The Fads before the Court

.

(b) The Court’s Legal

Analysis.

3. The Concurring Opinions.

4. The Dissenting Opinions .

E. Trial Experts .

1. Plaintiffs’ Experts.

2. The Government’s Experts .

F. Abortion Procedures.

1. D&E .

2. D & X.

3. Induction.

4. Hysterectomy and Hysterotomy.

G. Trial Testimony Regarding Comparative Safety of Abortion Procedures . ^ O

1. Comparison of D & E to Induction. ^ O

2. Comparison of D & X to D & E. -3

H. Testimony Regarding Possibility of Effecting Fetal Demise Prior to Abortion Procedure . -3

I. Trial Testimony Regarding Congress’s Factual Findings . -3 CR

1. Congress’s Findings Regarding the Risks of “Partial-Birth Abortion”. —3 CR

2. Congress’s Findings Regarding Other Aspects of “Partial-Birth Abortion”. —3 00

II.FINDINGS OF FACT.479

III.CONCLUSIONS OF LAW.482

A. The Court Only Reaches the Health-Exception Issue.482

B. Level of Deference Owed to Congressional Findings.483

C. The Act Requires a Health Exception.487

IY. CONCLUSION. .492

Plaintiffs, a non-profit organization providing abortion services, and seven individual physicians, seek to permanently enjoin enforcement of the Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act of 2003, 18 U.S.C. § 1531 (the “Act”), which imposes potential criminal and civil penalties if a physician performs a certain abortion procedure.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.