District Court, E.D. Michigan August 5, 2004, 02-73948 (Honeywell International, Inc. v. ITT Industries, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-08-2004

DECISION ON CLAIM CONSTRUCTION

COHN, District Judge.

Table of Contents

I. Introduction.867

II. Background.868

A. General Background of the Invention .868

B. The’879 Patent .868

C. Claim 1 .869

D. The Problem.870

E. Prosecution History of the ’879 Patent.870

1. The’920 Parent Patent Application: “Method”.871

2. The ’084 Divisional Patent Application: “Fuel Filter”.871

3. The ’879 Divisional Patent Application: “Moldable Material”.872

a. Initial Examination.872

b. Reexamination.874

III. Claim Interpretation Generally.876

IV. Analysis.877

A. “Fuel Injection System Component for Communicating Fuel to the Engine of a Motor Vehicle”.878

1. Ordinary Meaning of the Claim Language.878

2. Specification.878

a. Applicable Law.878

b. Analysis.879

3. Prosecution History.881

a. Applicable Law.881

i. Biogen.881

ii. Housey.882

b. Analysis.882

4. Conclusion.883

B. “Electrically Conductive Fibers”.883

C. “A Conductive Member Leading to Said Electrical Plane”.885

D. “Thereby Prevent the Build-up of Electrostatic Charge in the Fuel and the Resultant Arcing Which Causes the Breakdown of the Polymer Material Comprising the Fuel Injection System Component”.887

V. Conclusion.887

I. Introduction

This is a patent case. Plaintiffs Honeywell International, Inc. and Honeywell Intellectual Properties, Inc. (collectively, Honeywell), holders of U.S. Patent No. 5,164,879 (the ’879 patent) and Reexamination Certificate B1 5,164,879 covering an “Electrostatically Dissipative Fuel Filter,” are suing defendants ITT Industries, Inc., ppT Automotive, Inc., TG North America Corporation, TG Fluid Systems USA Corporation, and A. Raymond, Inc. for infringement of the ’879 patent.

1

Claim 1 has been designated as the paradigm claim.

2

Before the Court are the parties’

*868

papers relating to interpretation of the ambiguous terms in claim 1 of the ’879 patent. The Court conducted a

Markman

hearing

3

on May 25, 2004. The Court’s findings are described below.

II. Background

A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.