District Court, D. Minnesota May 26, 2004, CIV.03-2631(RHK/RLE) (Lao v. Hartford Life and Accident Ins. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-05-2004

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

KYLE, District Judge.

Introduction

Between July 1, 1996, and October 1, 1998, St. Mary’s Duluth Clinic in Duluth, Minnesota sponsored a long-term disability insurance plan (“the Plan”) for its employees through Hartford Life and Accident Insurance Company (“Hartford”). Under the Plan, a participant suffering a twenty-reduction in “current! ] earning[s]” due to disability is entitled to residual disability benefits. Dr. Antonio Lao, a physician at the Duluth Clinic, filed for benefits after he reduced his practice because of heart disease. Because the Clinic pays its physicians advances based on projected productivity, Lao’s paycheck was not reduced until he was required to return excess advances the next fiscal year. Hartford — whose agreement with the Clinic expired

before

the end of the fiscal year — denied Lao’s claim on the ground that his earnings were not affected during the plan period. Lao brought suit under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (“ERISA”), and both sides have moved for summary judgment.

This case presents a narrow legal issue: Was it reasonable for Hartford to calculate Lao’s current earnings based on the money he wa,s advanced, rather than the money to which his actual productivity entitled him? The Court finds that it was not. Therefore, for the reasons below, the Court will grant Lao’s motion and deny Hartford’s motion.

1

Background

In late 1997, Dr. Antonio Lao, a fifty-nine-year-old internist at St. Mary’s Duluth Clinic in Duluth, Minnesota, suffered chest pains and shortness of breath. (Meyers Aff. Ex. 1 at 89.) Lao’s cardiologist diagnosed him' with chronic atrial fibrillation and intermittent bardycardia.

{Id-

at 92.) Atrial fibrillation is

a disorder found in about 2 million Americans. In it the heart’s two small upper chambers (the atria) quiver instead of beating effectively. Blood isn’t pumped completely ‘out of them, so it may pool and clot.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.