District Court, D. Puerto Rico May 17, 2004, CR. 03-55(SEC) (United States v. Ayala Lopez)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-05-2004

*237

ORDER

CASELLAS, District Judge.

Pending before the Court are several motions for severance filed by Co-defendant Carlos Ayala López (Docket # 270), José A. Ramos Romero (Docket # 269), and José L. Medina Ortiz (Docket # 280).

1

The Government has opposed all motions (Docket # 285). After carefully considering and weighing all the applicable factors presented by counsel, for the reasons stated herein, Defendants’ motions to sever will be GRANTED.

Procedural Background

This case posits a complicated scenario for the issue of severance as there are three remaining non-capital defendants as well as a Co-defendant, Carlos Ayala Lopez, who if convicted, faces a possible sentence of death, and together with Co-defendants is charged with Counts One and Two of the Indictment,

2

but is the only defendant charged with Counts Three and Four. For this reason, this Court on December 25, 2003 determined that this was a complex case and, as such, held in abeyance the Speedy Trial Act’s deadlines (Docket # 204). The present case is further compounded by the possibility that the Government may file a superceding indictment to include Male Juvenile E.L.C. who has appealed District Court Judge Hector Laffitte’s ruling transferring him to adult status. The First Circuit has yet to assign a hearing date on his appeal.

Applicable Law and Analysis

Rule 14(a) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure provides that:

If the joinder of offenses or defendants in an indictment, an information, or a consolidation for trial appears to prejudice a defendant or the government, the court may order separate trials of counts, sever the defendant’s trials, or provide any other relief that justice requires.

Using the prejudice standard as a backdrop, courts have recognized the preference in the federal system to jointly try defendants who are indicted together.

See Zafiro v. United States,

506 U.S. 534, 537, 113 S.Ct. 933, 122 L.Ed.2d 317 (1993).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.