Supreme Court of Arkansas January 8, 2004, 03-594 (Dupwe v. Wallace)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-01-2004
combined-opinion
140 S.W.3d 464 (2004) 355 Ark. 521 Warren E. DUPWE v. Frank G. WALLACE, and First State Bank, et al. No. 03-594. Supreme Court of Arkansas. January 8, 2004. *466 Bond & Chamberlin, Jacksonville, by: Will Bond and Neil Chamberlin; and Rees Law Firm, by: Thomas A. Young, West Memphis, for appellants. Wright, Lindsey & Jennings LLP, by: Gordon S. Rather, Jr. and James R. Van Dover, Little Rock, for appellees first State Bank, Parkin Bancorp, Inc., William N. Griffin, and certain others. Rieves, Rubens & Mayton, by: Elton A. Rieves IV, West Memphis, for appellee/cross-appellant Frank G. Wallace. JIM HANNAH, Justice. Bankruptcy Trustee Warren E. Dupwe appeals a summary judgment finding that he is judicially estopped from pursuing the tort claims of Chapter 7 bankruptcy petitioners Barry L. and Deborah L. Nix. The trial court found that when the Nixes failed to list claims against First State Bank, and its employees ("First State") in their bankruptcy petition, any future suit on the claim was precluded by judicial estoppel. Dupwe's tort action in Crittenden County was initially filed by the Nixes after their bankruptcy case was closed; however, when First State objected to the Nixes bringing the action after their discharge *467 in bankruptcy, the bankruptcy case was reopened, and bankruptcy trustee Dupwe was substituted in the place of the Nixes as plaintiff in the lawsuit. A prima facie case of judicial estoppel includes four elements: 1. A party must assume a position clearly inconsistent with a position taken in an earlier case, or with a position taken in the same case; 2. A party must assume the inconsistent position with the intent to manipulate the judicial process to gain an unfair advantage; 3. A party must have successfully maintained the position in an earlier proceeding such that the court relied upon the position taken; and, 4.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit